Can You Replace Vinyl Siding or Stucco with Hardiplank?

When it comes time to replace the siding on your home, there are a variety of siding products to choose from, and you’re not necessarily restricted by the siding material you currently have. That said, can you replace vinyl siding or stucco with HardiPlank? The answer to that question is generally yes. You can always remove the old siding and replace it with something new. But is it practical?

Replacing Vinyl Siding With HardiPlank

This is a straightforward conversion that happens all the time throughout North America and is just as simple a process as replacing old fiber cement siding with new fiber cement or vinyl siding. The first phase is to remove the old siding and dispose of it properly. The installers will then inspect the structure of the home, and if everything is OK, they will prep the surface for the new installation and, finally, install the new HardiPlank just as if they were putting it on a newly built house.

Replacing Stucco With HardiPlank

You can replace stucco siding with HardiPlank as well, but it’s important to note that the process is more labor-intensive and thus usually more expensive. The cost will depend on the size of the home but also the condition of the stucco if there is water and other damage, the stucco can be more difficult to remove. Expect the process to take longer than removing vinyl, which usually happens in a single day.

Installing HardiPlank Over Stucco

There is an alternative to replacing stucco that is much less expensive and time intensive. This process involves making sure that all of the stucco is in sound condition and then creating a seal. Once that seal is completed, the HardiPlank is installed over the old siding, and the stucco simply serves as an additional moisture barrier.

Should You Replace Vinyl Siding and Stucco With HardiPlank?

While the answer to “Can you replace vinyl siding or stucco with HardiPlank?”, is yes, the next question is, should you? Many experts agree that HardiPlank is the superior siding material currently used in North America and that you should move on from stucco if possible as it’s more prone to water damage than other siding materials. The debate between HardiPlank and vinyl is certainly more interesting. Vinyl siding does need less maintenance, but if you’re willing to have your siding power washed once a year and repainted every five to 10 years, the HardiPlank will deliver superior curb appeal, performance, durability, and longevity.

NexGen Installs HardiPlank

If you own a home in New Jersey or Pennsylvania and are considering HardiPlank installation, contact NexGen Exterior Home Remodeling for a free estimate. Our team has extensive experience installing HardiPlank and replacing stucco, vinyl, and fiber cement siding. We also encourage you to call us at 215-277-7630 or contact us online if you have any additional questions about “Can you replace vinyl siding or stucco with HardiPlank?”.